Who should have their say…who decides


voltaire quoteIf you believe in

1/ the freedom of speech,
2/ the rights of any individual to hold whatever view they so desire, and
3/ the right to do so when ever they feel such views should be aired,

then what do you do when views are expressed to you that are generally considered to be beyond the pale.

Under such circumstances who has the right to have their say, and whois to decide whether their voice or opinions should be heard

I have spoken before about such matters in such posts as Human Rights-whose do we observe, and Free Speech Rules Ok, but a recent conversation with a co-worker left me deep in thought and rather disturbed.

The gentleman concerned is in his 30’s and we were viewing a group of “mentally handicapped” individuals as, with their carers or caregivers, they walked round the store. I had far more sympathy with their condition than my colleague, as I have had my own troubles with severe depression in the past, but I was disturbed to hear him coming out with simplistic views on eugenics, euthanasia and patient selection based on mental awareness and capacity and their ability to lead fully independent lives.

Under certain circumstances I would have been severely tempted to refute such views but as he spoke I came to a couple of rather sobering realisations

  1. Did I have the right to try and correct his views or silence him
  2. As his views were born out of historical ignorance should I have “re-educated ” him and, in doing so
  3. What right did I have, if any , to say he was mistaken in his views, and to say that he should adjust his views

By my own admission I went for a compromise solution, a very uncomfortable solution, yet on which seemed to be the best on the day.

 

  1. I gently questioned him about his attitude and reminded him of  historical eugenic processes, and The ActionT4 program within Nazi German
  2. I enquired as to where any line of incapacity should be drawn as regards Physical disability or illness (should such ,loathsome terms be applied.
  3. I very carefully pointed out that as he had never been in such shoes it was very difficult for him to understand their position, or speak worth any authority as to what benefits they might bring to society as a whole.
  4. Finally I reminded him of several pertinent points of history, and indicated where, if he chose to do so, further information might be found

Why was I so carefull and gentle, well, see below

  1. I had to still work alongside him
  2. I have come to know him well, and I know such views are born out of ignorance rather than any kind if racism, shallow thought, or cruelty to those with a percieved disability
  3. I was loathe to deny him a freedom of thought and speech which I myself wished to both enjoy and deploy, and
  4. Though I disliked his solution and simple reasoning, I could see that he was trying to find a solution to a problem of prolonged health care which will undoubtedly increase over the years

So in this post which is full of unresolved questions, I pose another such series of questions, about which I would love to hear your views

  1. What would you said had you been in my shoes
  2. How much freedom of thought ans speech should br granted to any individual
  3. Should any subjects or views be considered off limits or universally unacceptable
  4. If so, what subjects, and where should such a line be drawn

 

Happily, I can can report that he stated that I had given him something to think about, but whatever the final result of our conversation, the core problems raised within this post remain.

So if you have time, and you wish to do so, help me out here, as without any question, I find myself precariously balancing between several stools.

Oh yes, one last thing. You will see that I have put in two You Tube videos, both of which are intense in nature. I make no apologies for doing so, as they reflect serious issues which affect us all.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Advertisements


Categories: Just a thought

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , ,

Your views and your comments are invaluable, so I'd love to hear from you. Please leave a comment or a reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Let me tell U a story

An article blog for the short story author Chris Wilson, a special project site dedicated to supporting all those affected by depression and other related illnesses, and a site for all those who either love to think differently, or who love the English language

My Wonderland. Mental Health Blog

Finding normality within Bipolarity. The inner musings of a chemically challenged manic-depressive. Mildly* asocial and a purveyor of awesome.

Karen Wilson_ Awaken

Tools for Personal Development

Writing Compulsion

Compulsively creating reality, with a little bit of the unreal.

Jennifer Michelle Jones

Writing things you wouldn't repeat in polite company...

The Elephant in the Room

Writing about my experiences with: depression, anxiety, OCD and Aspergers

maggiemaeijustsaythis

through the darkness there is light

Youth Of A Nation:Bent not Broke

Not all wounds are visible

Myshelle Congeries

I Bleed Words Sometimes

Be Good or Be Good At It!

Real Life...only Funnier!

Julian Stodd's Learning Blog

A place to explore new ideas in Learning

Otrazhenie

Reflection

HorrorPublishing.com - Horror Press Publishing

Chris Mentillo Official Social Media Site

Storytime with John

Pull up and listen...I've got a funny one for ya...

Vampire Maman

Musings of a Modern Vampire Mom

K.S.@ksfinblog: Global Analyst

Scientist - Open invitation to people from charities and Not for profit corporations

Coffee. Write. Repeat.

Writing my way through life, one word at a time.

Heather SinnerElla Hoe

Voice of Health and Body Image

I'm Good: A Blog Campaign for Mental Health Recovery

I've struggled. I'm growing. I'm good.

%d bloggers like this: